Use a consistent scorecard
For each firm, record jurisdiction, relevant matter experience, proposed team, communication plan, conflicts, fee terms, expense terms, and the next recommended step.
Verify objective details
Check license information with the relevant authority and confirm office, contact, and practice information directly. Treat awards, case results, and reviews as claims that require context.
Compare the proposed route
Ask each firm to explain the immediate priorities, missing information, likely stages, and major decision points. A useful explanation should acknowledge uncertainty rather than promise an outcome.
Make the decision deliberately
Consider whether the agreement is understandable, your questions were answered, and the proposed communication arrangement works for you. You may decline representation or seek another opinion.